When Performance Reviews Become Elimination Rounds
By Peter Tannenbaum, CEO
As the year draws to a close, finance professionals are heading into performance reviews, compensation decisions and the career moves that often follow in the first quarter. Layoff headlines get the attention. But there is another kind of job loss that deserves a closer look. It can happen even when the business is healthy and a team is performing well.
Put ten capable professionals on the same team and someone still finishes tenth. In a system that requires the lowest ranked people to leave, that person can lose a job despite doing good work. That is the uncomfortable logic behind forced ranking, sometimes called rank and yank.
Where the Idea Came From
The most famous example was General Electric’s 20/70/10 model. Under that approach, the top 20% received the highest recognition, 70% occupied the middle and the bottom 10% were identified for dismissal. The idea was to keep raising the standard by continually replacing the lowest ranked employees.
There is a critical distinction here. Being at the bottom of a group does not necessarily mean being a poor performer. A team can exceed its targets, serve its clients exceptionally well and still have a bottom 10%. Relative rank measures position within a group. It does not independently establish whether someone is capable or valuable.
Not every company that uses a performance curve automatically fires the people at the bottom. Some impose limits on top ratings. Others connect rankings more directly to terminations. Both create pressure, but they are not the same policy. The distinction matters when we discuss what is actually happening inside a firm.
What Has Been Reported on Wall Street
There is documented history behind this conversation. Fortune reported in 2022 that Goldman Sachs had, before the pandemic, routinely removed the bottom 5% of its workforce, sometimes more, based on performance reviews. Bloomberg subsequently reported that several major Wall Street banks were resuming periodic cuts of employees considered underperformers.
In 2025, Reuters reported that Goldman planned reductions of 3% to 5% through its annual performance review. The bank described that as part of its normal annual talent management process. Reporting in March 2026 also described plans for selective cuts aimed at underperforming employees, separate from the regular annual exercise.
These are reports about particular years and decisions. They do not establish that Goldman or any other major financial firm currently has a permanent rule requiring a fixed percentage to be fired. The numbers and processes can differ by year, firm and business unit.
The terminology has also changed. Firms are more likely to speak about talent management or performance based reductions than rank and yank. Sometimes that description is appropriate. An employee may genuinely fall short of reasonable expectations. But where a forced distribution shapes the outcome, the label alone can conceal an important question: Was the person actually performing poorly, or simply ranked below strong colleagues?
This is not the same as a layoff caused by shrinking demand, a strategic change or a reorganization. It is a decision driven by an individual’s place in the performance assessment process. That is precisely why candidates and employers should understand the difference.
The Cost of Ranking Strong People
A Cornell Chronicle report in August 2025 highlighted research published in Management Science examining a large company’s forced ranking system. The study found that high achievers who were denied top ratings because of a cap were more likely to leave voluntarily than colleagues who received those ratings.
That research did not study mandatory firing quotas. It studied the consequences of restricting recognition. Still, its finding is directly relevant: a ranking system can push valuable employees out even when management wants them to stay. The lesson is that the way a firm recognizes performance can influence whether its strongest people stay.
There is a practical cost to that. Firms invest years in developing judgment, client relationships, institutional knowledge and trust. Losing an effective person because of an artificial cutoff can undo some of that investment. An evaluation system should help management distinguish meaningful performance differences, not manufacture weakness where it does not exist.
If You Are Being Ranked
The first step is understanding your firm’s process. Ask how ratings are determined, whether people are assessed against defined standards or directly against colleagues, and whether ratings are calibrated across teams. A manager may not disclose every detail, but you should know what results count and how success is evaluated.
Keep a record of your contributions. For investment professionals, that may include investment decisions, risk discipline or portfolio outcomes. For bankers and private equity professionals, it may mean transactions, client work or execution. For wealth advisors, it may include client retention, new assets, planning quality and relationship development. Make the evidence specific to your responsibilities.
Finally, do not let a review calendar make every career decision for you. That does not mean starting a search at the first sign of uncertainty. It means knowing your market, maintaining relationships and understanding your options before someone else determines your timing. One internal ranking is not the final measure of your professional worth.
If You Are Hiring, Look More Closely
From our vantage point at Ramax Search & Staffing, a candidate’s departure is the beginning of a conversation, not the conclusion. We recruit across hedge funds, private equity, banking and wealth management, where the circumstances surrounding an exit can be as important as the exit itself.
A hiring manager should ask what the person actually delivered, how the role was measured, who the comparison group was and what changed. Was there a substantiated performance problem? Was the job eliminated? Or did a capable individual fall on the wrong side of a relative ranking? Each possibility calls for a different assessment.
We are not suggesting that every person affected by a performance review is a star. We are saying that the label underperformer is not a substitute for diligence. The lowest ranked employee on a very strong team can still be an outstanding hire for a different organization.
As year end reviews finish and first quarter hiring begins, employers who make that distinction may find talent others overlook. Professionals who understand the distinction can make more informed decisions about their own careers.
If everyone on a team is performing well, should someone still have to be the person who leaves?

